Apartments in Jamaica Plain Under $4,500 for Rent

Entire place in 242 South Huntington Ave. - Jamaica Plain

1 Bed 1 Bath 581 sq ft

$2,700, Rent

Avail. Jul 1, 2026

Entire place in 9-11 Woodside Ave. - Jamaica Plain

3 Beds 1 Bath 0 sq ft

$2,895, Rent

Avail. Apr 22, 2026

Entire place in 12 Arcola St. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 1 Bath 860 sq ft

$3,400, Rent

Avail. Jul 1, 2026

Entire place in 14 Haverford St. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 1 Bath 883 sq ft

$3,200, Rent

Avail. Jun 1, 2026

+2 similar units available

Private room in 185 Green St. - Jamaica Plain

1 Bed 1 Bath

$1,200, Rent

Avail. Apr 1, 2026

Entire place in 271 Chestnut Ave. - Jamaica Plain

1 Bed 1 Bath 600 sq ft

$2,400, Rent

Avail. Jun 1, 2026

Entire place in 11 Sheridan St. - Jamaica Plain

3 Beds 1 Bath 1300 sq ft

$3,600, Rent

Avail. Jul 1, 2026

Entire place in 3145 Washington - Jamaica Plain

4 Beds 1 Bath 1400 sq ft

$3,500, Rent

Avail. Apr 21, 2026

No photo

+1 similar unit available

Entire place in 53 South Huntington - Jamaica Plain

Studio 1 Bath

$1,800, Rent

Avail. Jun 1, 2026

No photo

Entire place in 51 South Huntington - Jamaica Plain

Studio 1 Bath

$1,750, Rent

Avail. May 1, 2026

No photo

+1 similar unit available

Entire place in 53 South Huntington - Jamaica Plain

Studio 1 Bath

$1,695, Rent

Avail. Apr 1, 2026

Entire place in 76 Stonley Rd. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 2 Baths 1000 sq ft

$3,300, Rent

Avail. Sep 1, 2026

Entire place in 50 Stedman St. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 2 Baths 1100 sq ft

$3,320, Rent

Avail. Jun 1, 2026

Entire place in 265 Hyde Park Ave. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 1 Bath 900 sq ft

$2,355, Rent

Avail. May 1, 2026

No photo

Entire place in 59 South Huntington - Jamaica Plain

1 Bed 1 Bath

$2,300, Rent

Avail. Apr 1, 2026

Entire place in 6 Wise St. - Jamaica Plain

3 Beds 1 Bath 9999 sq ft

$3,700, Rent

Avail. Sep 1, 2026

+4 similar units available

Entire place in 201 South Huntington Ave. - Jamaica Plain

Studio 1 Bath 536 sq ft

$3,231, Rent

Avail. Jul 13, 2026

Entire place in 23 Goldsmith St. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 1 Bath 1031 sq ft

$4,000, Rent

Avail. Jul 1, 2026

+1 similar unit available

Entire place in 161 South Hungtinton Ave. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 2 Baths 1032 sq ft

$4,375, Rent

Avail. Jun 17, 2026

Entire place in 335 South Huntington Ave. - Jamaica Plain

2 Beds 1 Bath 720 sq ft

$3,100, Rent

Avail. Jun 1, 2026

All apartments in the neighborhood of Jamaica Plain under $4,500